Rules

By -
I've been rather involved in a couple of blog discussions recently about how Evangelical Christians and Latter-day Saints interact, and in the midst of all this, a discussion about rules for LDS missionaries has developed. In an effort to not sidetrack the original posts on those blogs, but to still let my thoughts flow free, I thought I'd pose a question to you folks out there reading this blog:

What is the purpose of having rules?

I've been pondering this question for far too long, I'm sure, but I still haven't really come up with a definite, satisfactory answer, but I'd be glad to know your thoughts on the matter. So please, share with the class!

Comments

Unknown said…
Do you mean "why do missionaries have rules" or "why do we (in general) have rules"?

One answer to the former question might be: to establish discipline. Perhaps you could even say, to establish the expectations of a contract (or in religious parlance, a covenant). Now, understanding somewhat where Evangelicals are coming from theologically, I'd venture to say they might have a problem with that kind of answer-- ultimately discussions between our respective groups tend to lead to each side judging the other side's arguments through their own framework of understanding. And of course argument B doesn't fit with framework A, because it was designed for framework B!

The answer to the latter... well, depending on your political bent there might be all sorts of answers. I suppose the one that everyone should agree with is to create a fair society that best maintains and encourages peaceful interactions between its citizens. I don't know that there's any kind of religious aspect to that, and even atheists would generally agree that society requires some form of basic morality to prevent self-destruction.
October 19, 2009 at 3:01 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Crafty Craftiness

By -
Image
So... um, so much for writing a new blog post once a week. I don't even remember how long it took for me to stop. I keep meaning to update, but then life happens and I don't get around to it. I probably have too many blogs that I try to keep up with in the first place. I update my teaching blog every day there is school. I update the million minutes blog a few times each month, and I thoroughly neglect the GreedCycle blog that Gretch and I started over a year ago. Anyway, Gretch and I have had a lot going on, but since we really don't  want our blog to be just medical updates, I haven't been writing about them. And since the day-to-day activities of our lives rarely seem to be "blog-worthy" (other than my teaching which, as already mentioned, is blogged about elsewhere), I end up not updating this blog as much as I probably should. Who knows, maybe I'll get back into the swing of things this year. New year, new chance to hold myself to a standard of u
Read more

Is Civil Discourse Too Much To Ask For?

By -
As I am pretty certain everyone reading this blog knows, I am an active participant on several different blogs, many of them related to religion, politics, education, and social issues. In a recent blog post at By Common Consent, a Mormon blog, about immigration, a nugget was posted by a (to the best of my knowledge) drive-by commenter, ranting and raving about "illegals" ruining our nation. Here is the verbatim post: Do illegals pay social security? Millions of dollars are sent back to Mexico to their families. And their are jobs besides farm jobs that that citizens haven’t done because wages have been depressed by importing them at a cheaper rate. A condition of higher unemployment means that any race, Irish etal takes opportunities from those who first deserve them. Eventually, the citizen would take any job to survive if they hadn’t already been taken by then. If no citizen needed that job, then I wouldn’t care about that aspect of it. But their is a coverup of statistic
Read more

And This Is Life Eternal

By -
Many of you know that I am a professional educator. I work in the Freeport School District as the Curriculum Coordinator for 21st Century Teaching and Learning. Whenever I have the opportunity to share this with others upon meeting them for the first time, one of the first questions I get is, “Is that your real hair?” Apparently, there are things people care about more than know what it means to coordinate the teaching and learning efforts of an entire century. (The answer, by the way, is yes, this is my real hair; no, I don’t dye it; yes, it really is this curly; and no, you cannot touch it to see if it is actually a wig.)  Once I am able to get the discussion about my amazing naturally curly hair out of the way, we get back to the question of what it is I actually do. My favourite way to describe my job is that I am a teacher of teachers and that my main responsibility is to get them to put away the worksheets and step away from the PowerPoint so that they can engage their student
Read more