Morality and Legislation

By -
I'm sure you've heard it before. A "moral" issue shows up in political discussions, and it eventually makes its way to the ballot. The opposition tends to have just one rallying cry: "You can't legislate morality!"

I am curious about this refrain, and about this concept, in general. There are some things that are on ballots that are not moral issues: candidates, for instance. Tax increases. Pretty much, anything that isn't making one thing or another illegal.

On the other hand, aren't all laws legislated morality? What is "morality" anyway? According to Dictionary.com, morality is "conformity to the rules of right conduct". Are not all laws "rules of conduct"? And is not the purpose of legislation to promote conformity to said rules? Now, obviously, you cannot actually force anybody to conform to anything. Heck, you can't force anybody to do anything. Well, I suppose you could drug somebody to a mindless stupor and then lead them along like a puppet, but are they actually doing something if someone is doing it for them? Probably not. But, with laws, we are at least trying to convince the populace that conformity is a preferred route to take. After all, the laws pretty much say, "Conform, and there are no worries! Don't conform, and you go to jail or pay a fine!"

So, really, to my way of thinking, not only can you legislate morality, we are constantly doing it, every time we pass laws. So what's with the all the to-do about legislating morality? I think the opposition needs a better refrain than, "Anarchy! Anarchy! Anarchy!" Because, really, that is what they mean, every time they shun legislated morality. If all legislation is moral, then amoral legislation is non-legislation. And non-legislation is anarchy.

Personally, I prefer the moral legislation.

Comments

Unknown said…
I think you could even make the argument that taxes are legislated morality, since they go to fund programs that society (or at least those parts of society that have sympathetic ears in Congress) thinks is good. Welfare, Afghanistan/Iraq, and the bank bailout immediately come to mind. Not that I'm making any statement about the goodness/badness of those examples, just that we pay for them regardless of our own personal feelings for these programs, or suffer the consequences of tax evasion laws.
November 13, 2008 at 9:44 AM
America said…
I just discovered your blog! Yay I hope you guys are doing well!
November 13, 2008 at 11:17 AM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Who Am I? On Iconography, Faith, and Self-Identity

By -
Image
In one of the great classic works of French literature, the author Victor Hugo tells the story of Jean Valjean, a man who spent nineteen years in prison, growing angrier and more filled with hate toward the world with each passing day. The first five years were for stealing a loaf of bread to feed his sister’s starving family, but then he suffered for fourteen additional years for attempting to run away. The story of Les Misérables follows his journey from his release from prison on parole to a life of service, sacrifice, love, mercy, grace, and, ultimately, redemption. In the musical adaptation of this story, a pivotal moment takes place early in the story when Jean Valjean, who had been gifted a meal and safe shelter for the night from a kindly bishop, gives in to temptation, steals the bishop’s silverware and runs off, only to be captured by the local constables. Valjean claims that the silver was given as a gift from the bishop but the police, not believing the words of a cri...
Read more

Make A Joyful Noise

By -
My father-in-law recently blogged about music, and lamented that Western society does not produce music except for the purpose of providing entertaining diversions. While I am sorely tempted to link to his blog, I will refrain. Rather, I wish to simply present my own thoughts on why I consume music. And consume it I do. I love music. I devour it. It is a part of my being. Gretch and I almost always have music playing in our home, in the car, and when we are working (and can get away with it). I do not know when my love of music first emerged, but I would argue that it has always been with me. My own father is a talented musician, although I fear there are times when this talent has been hidden from the world. Yet some of my earliest recollections of my childhood include Dad breaking out his amazingly awesome Martin D35 acoustic guitar and playing songs like "The Lion Sleeps Tonight" by The Tokens, "Boogie" by John Hartford, and various songs from the world of classi...
Read more

Who Are You?

By -
A thought has been running through my mind this morning and it doesn't seem to be planning on leaving any time soon. I have things I need to get done (such as applying for more jobs for the coming school year), so I am hoping that this may help me at least share the thought well enough that I can worry about other things. The thought is really more of a question. Who am I? Who are you? How do I define myself? How do you define yourself? So often in our lives, we have opportunities to introduce ourselves to new people. I've mentioned before how I have this habit of introducing myself as Alex Valencic but, if I am writing my name, it is always Alex T. Valencic. After sharing my name, it is inevitable that someone will want to know more about me, and the first thing they ask is what I do. How we respond to this question says a lot about what we think of ourselves, I think. When someone asks me what I do, I respond by either saying I am a teacher or I am a professional educat...
Read more